Appraising Vintage Video Games: Determining the Value of Retro Gaming Treasures

July 9, 2023
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Table of Contents

What is the value of a vintage video game today?

The value of a vintage video game today may vary depending on a number of factors, including the game's condition, its rarity, age, and its original retail price. Generally, the older a game is, the more valuable it is, and the rarer and more sought-after games can go for thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars. Games that are in good condition usually fetch higher prices. For instance, the original Nintendo Entertainment System game, Super Mario Bros, can be sold for anywhere between $20 and $100 if in good condition. The Nintendo World Championship cartridge has been sold for $100,000. Other particularly rare and sought-after games include Stadium Events (NES) and the Nintendo Campus Challenge (NES). Similar to vintage cars or furniture, the value of a vintage video game can be determined by an appraiser to ensure that the buyer and seller get a fair deal.

How can an appraiser assess the worth of a vintage video game?

When appraising vintage video games, an appraiser must first gather information about the game's condition, age, edition, and historical context. Condition is particularly important to consider, as scratches on the game can affect its worth. The condition of both the game’s packaging and instruction booklets should also be assessed. Next, the appraiser should determine the age of the game. Knowing the exact time in which it was released provides the appraiser with a better understanding of its context. The edition of the video game should also be determined. Many vintage games were released in different versions, all with varying prices. An appraiser must be aware of which edition the game is in order to accurately assess its worth. Finally, the appraiser must evaluate the historical context of the game. It’s important to consider how rare or exclusive the game is, and the amount of nostalgia it might evoke in collectors. The game’s current popularity and demand can also affect its price. By considering all these factors, an appraiser can give a more accurate assessment of a vintage video game’s worth.

How does age factor into the appraisal of vintage video games?

Age is one of the most important criteria to consider when appraising vintage video games. Generally, the older a game is, the more valuable it is. Games that are more than 20 years old are deserving of careful evaluation. Collectors often recognize the value of historic importance, as well as rarity in older games. Age is so important to a game's value, because some of the older games are no longer in production or hard to find in good condition. So, collectors place a high priority on condition and age when assessing worth and value. Furthermore, with certain games, the value may be based not just on its age, but on the limited production of the specific game. The rarity of a game will drive up the value, especially if it has become a classic. Therefore, age can be a major factor when appraising vintage video games.

What factors should be considered when appraising vintage video games?

When appraising vintage video games, there are several important factors to consider. First, it's important to think about the condition of the game. Is it complete? Does it have any visible damage? These questions will help to determine the true value of the game. Second, consider the rarity of the game. It should come as no surprise that rarer games will often be more valuable than more common games. A game's history and reputation can also play a role in its value. Third, look at the game's packaging. Does it include the original manual or any related accessories? It's not just about the condition of the game, but also the condition of the item as a whole. Finally, take into account the current market demand for the game. Has the game's price gone up or down in recent years? Is it still popular? Knowing the demand for the game will also help to gauge its value. These are just a few of the factors that should be considered when appraising vintage video games. With that said, it's important to remember that the true value of the game lies in the eyes of the collector.

Are there any rare vintage video games that are particularly valuable?

Yes, some vintage video games are particularly valuable. Some examples of rare and highly collectible video games include the original 1981 Nintendo Game & Watch titles, the first releases of Super Mario Bros. (1985), the limited edition Zelda: Ocarina of Time 3D (2011), and the original Red, Blue, and Yellow Pokémon games (1998). These games have remained popular and sought-after for many years, and their values have only increased over time. For example, a copy of the 1985 Super Mario Bros. game recently sold for $114,000, while a copy of Pokémon Red was recently sold for $84,000. It's important to note that the value of these titles may vary depending on factors like condition, the rarity of the game, and any special features such as limited editions or exclusive contents. With proper research and care, many vintage video games can become true treasures.

Can the condition of a vintage video game affect its appraisal?

Absolutely. The condition of a vintage video game can have a strong effect on its appraisal. For instance, games that are scratched or otherwise physically damaged can be more challenging to resell, and may in turn be appraised at a lower value. Additionally, games with loose connections or aged parts may not be as playable as they once were, and may not be worth as much as a pristine game of the same model. The age of the game is also factored in when appraising its value, as certain models may be 'retro' or rare, and thus be worth more than newer games. Collectors also value authenticity, and will often pay more for games in their original box with their original parts. Ultimately, condition matters when it comes to appraising vintage video games.

What is the difference between appraising a vintage video game and a retro video game?

Appraising a vintage video game is more difficult than appraising a retro video game for a few reasons. Vintage video games, which are typically those released in the 1980s and early 1990s, usually have more rarity and historical significance than games released later in the '90s and 2000s. These older titles also tend to have higher resale values, as there is more interest from collectors and enthusiasts who want to experience their childhood games. Retro video games, on the other hand, are those released mainly in the mid to late '90s and 2000s, and have slightly different values. Rare games and those with sought-after elements can still fetch a good price, but they tend to be much more common and have less demand than those from the earlier years. A skilled appraiser will be able to identify the distinctions between antique and retro video games.

What kind of documentation is typically needed when appraising a vintage video game?

When appraising a vintage video game, there are a few pieces of documentation that are typically needed. Depending on the type of game, the age and condition, and the source or provenance, the appraiser will need to collect different information. An original receipt or purchase order is often useful in verifying authenticity, and any paperwork that came with the game like a manual or instructions can add to the value. Ownership documents such as bills of sale can demonstrate a game's history and be important factors when establishing the appraised value. Photographs can be helpful in showing condition, particularly for game boxes and consoles, as well as for any other cartridges, controllers, or related items. Even the original packaging materials like the styrofoam can be important for a complete appraisal. Although each appraisal is unique, having the right documentation on hand is essential to get the most accurate appraisal of a vintage video game.

What other information should an appraiser look for when appraising a vintage video game?

When appraising a vintage video game, an appraiser should seek out as much information as possible about the game and its potential value. Other than the game's condition, the age and rarity of the game are important factors to consider. For example, some of the earliest video game systems (such as the Atari 2600) have become increasingly sought after over the years, and are worth significantly more than games released during the same era. Moreover, if a game is a limited edition or has an interesting backstory, that could add value to the game as well. When possible, the appraiser should attempt to verify the authenticity of the game. For instance, if the game was used by a celebrity during their career, verifying its authenticity and history could add further value to the game. Additionally, appraisers should be aware of potential fakes or reproductions of rare or expensive games, and that reproductions may be worth a fraction of the original. In general, an appraiser should exercise professional judgment and take into account existing market conditions and trends when determining the value of a vintage video game. By doing so, they can ensure that their valuation is accurate and fair.

What should someone do to ensure they get an accurate appraisal for their vintage video game?

When looking to get an accurate appraisal for their vintage video games, there are a few steps someone can take. First, they should seek out an experienced and knowledgeable appraiser who specializes in vintage video games. This type of appraiser should have an understanding of the value of these collectibles, as well as knowledge of the market, so that they can provide a reliable estimate. They should also provide you with a detailed written appraisal that includes a description of the item, any flaws or damage, as well as a final estimated value. Additionally, it's important to have the item professionally photographed and document any provenance or past ownership. Providing this evidence can make it easier for the appraiser to determine the value of the game. Finally, it's important to be patient and understand the process, as getting a reliable appraisal can take some time. Taking these steps can help ensure that someone gets an accurate appraisal for their vintage video game.

Related Appraisals We Offer

We'd love to help with your appraisal!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Related Articles