How is fair market value different from fair value under GAAP?
FMV uses a hypothetical willing buyer and seller without compulsion, and often applies discounts for lack of control or marketability for private interests. Fair value under ASC 820 is an exit price between market participants and can produce materially higher results without those discounts. Using GAAP fair value instead of IRS FMV on a tax return can lead to disallowed deductions or penalties on forms like Form 8283.
What discounts apply to private business interests under FMV?
Two common discounts apply to non-publicly traded interests. A discount for lack of control (DLOC) reduces value for minority stakes that lack voting power, typically 20 to 40%. A discount for lack of marketability (DLOM) accounts for illiquidity, typically 20 to 50%. Combined, these discounts can reduce value 30 to 60% compared to a controlling interest, consistent with Revenue Ruling 59-60.
What is the valuation date for a charitable contribution?
The valuation date is the contribution date, meaning the date the property actually transfers, not the date an agreement is signed. This is defined under IRS Publication 561 and §1.170A-17. Using a later transaction date risks IRS adjustment if market conditions changed, which can result in a disallowed deduction.
What happens if my appraisal is missing required elements?
A qualified appraisal under §1.170A-17 must include the property description, valuation and contribution dates, appraiser qualifications and fee, FMV, methodology, and supporting basis such as comparables or earnings. Omitting any of these elements voids the appraisal's qualified status and can trigger penalties of 20 to 40% under IRC §6662 for substantial or gross valuation misstatements.
Why are synergy-based valuations excluded from FMV?
FMV assumes hypothetical market participants without specific synergies, not actual strategic buyers, per Revenue Ruling 59-60 and §20.2031-1(b). Including strategic buyer premiums would overstate value relative to what a typical willing buyer would pay, which the IRS does not accept for tax reporting purposes.