What is the difference between fair market value and fair value in an M&A appraisal?
Fair market value for tax purposes under Rev. Proc. 93-12 excludes deferred taxes and transaction costs, prioritizing liquid assets before depreciables and goodwill. Fair value under ASC 805 for financial reporting includes deferred taxes and transaction costs and requires reconciliation with tax fair market value. Blending the two standards without reconciliation is a common and costly mistake.
What happens if the buyer and seller report different allocations on Form 8594?
Mismatched allocations between buyer and seller on Form 8594 trigger IRS audits that can expand beyond the deal to scrutinize the entire transaction. Both parties are required to file identical versions of the form with their federal tax returns for the transaction year. A well-documented appraisal with agreed-upon allocations is the most effective way to avoid this outcome.
Is there a minimum deal size that requires a purchase price allocation appraisal?
No. IRC Section 1060 applies to any sale of a group of assets constituting a trade or business, regardless of deal size. Any qualifying transfer triggers the purchase price allocation requirement.
When is Form 8594 due, and what should the purchase agreement include?
Form 8594 is due with the federal tax return for the transaction year, which is April 15 for calendar-year filers. Purchase agreements should include detailed asset descriptions, proposed IRS class allocations, valuation methods, appraiser credentials, and the basis for fair market value to ensure consistency between buyer and seller filings.
What are the most common mistakes to avoid on Form 8594?
- Mismatched buyer and seller allocations, which trigger audits
- Ignoring the ASC 805 business definition, which eliminates goodwill if the transfer does not qualify as a business
- Blending fair value and fair market value without reconciliation
- Using contingent appraiser fees, which the IRS disqualifies
- Overlooking Section 382 ownership change valuations when applicable