Gun Appraisal for Insurance Coverage

5.0 on Google110+ 5-star reviews

Gun appraisals for insurance coverage, prepared to support insurance submission. AppraiseItNow provides documented fair market valuations for collectible and rare guns, helping you secure scheduled coverage that pays out without depreciation disputes.

Get an instant response

DEFENSIBLE, USPAP-COMPLIANT FIREARMS APPRAISAL REPORTS — QUALIFIED FOR INSURANCE CARRIERS, UNDERWRITERS, AND AGENTS.

  • State Farm
  • Progressive Insurance
  • Chase
  • Allstate
  • GEICO
  • United States Courts
  • Nationwide Insurance
  • Bank of America
  • IRS

AppraiseItNow's personal property appraisers prepare your insurance appraisal

Between them, AppraiseItNow's personal property appraisers hold ISA and CAGA designations. These are a few of them, and our reports are written to USPAP for insurance carriers, underwriters, and agents.

Joe Kattan

Joe Kattan

Owner & CEO

Joe joined AppraiseItNow as a co-owner in 2022 and acquired the company in November 2024 to make a certified, USPAP-compliant appraisal as simple to order as anything else online. A former Bain & Company strategy consultant, Joe leads the entire team and specializes in strategy, growth, and the firm's tech capabilities.

Anne Hay

Anne Hay

Personal Property Appraiser

ISA Accredited Member with 30 years in the trade, from running estate sales and an auction gallery to appraising luxury apparel, furniture, artwork, antiques, and business assets, primarily for IRS tax filings.

Jason Dolph

Jason Dolph

Machinery & Equipment Appraiser

Third-generation auctioneer and CAGA Certified Appraiser with more than 20 years valuing machinery, equipment, vehicles, business assets, and estates for banks, attorneys, and trustees across the Carolinas.

Ashley Innes

Ashley Innes

Personal Property Appraiser

ISA Accredited Member specializing in Asian art, with a Master's from SOAS and a Postgraduate Diploma in Asian Art. Ashley chairs the ISA's Antiques, Furnishings, and Decorative Arts committee and appraises for charitable donation, insurance, and equitable distribution.

Aron Blue

Aron Blue

Client Success Manager

Manages each engagement from the first enquiry to the delivered report, and keeps you posted at every step along the way.

  • USPAPWritten to the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice
  • Replacement valueThe retail replacement cost carriers and adjusters schedule and settle against
  • International Society of AppraisersAccredited Member
  • Certified Appraisers Guild of AmericaCertified Appraiser
  • The Appraisal FoundationAuthorized by Congress as the source of appraisal standards

Antique Gun Appraisals for Insurance Coverage

AppraiseItNow provides certified appraisals of antique and collectible firearms to help owners secure scheduled coverage beyond the aggregate theft limits found in standard homeowners policies, which typically cap all firearms combined at $2,500 to $5,000. The relevant value standard for this purpose is fair market value, which reflects what a willing buyer would pay a willing seller in an open market and is the basis insurers use for agreed value coverage, locking in a payout amount without depreciation disputes at claim time. Our personal property appraisal services cover the full range of antique firearms, from pre-Civil War percussion revolvers to early 20th-century military surplus rifles.

We deliver appraisals both online and onsite across the United States, accommodating collectors who prefer to submit photographs and documentation remotely as well as those who want an appraiser to examine pieces in person. Whether you are adding a scheduled rider for a single high-value piece or documenting an entire collection for firearms insurance coverage, our reports include detailed descriptions, condition assessments, comparable sales data, and photographs that satisfy insurer requirements.

Antique and Collectible Guns We Appraise for Insurance

AppraiseItNow appraises a wide range of antique and collectible firearms that commonly require scheduled coverage documentation, including:

  • Pre-1899 antique firearms qualifying as antiques under federal definition, such as flintlock and percussion cap pistols and rifles
  • Civil War-era military longarms, including Springfield and Enfield muskets and carbines
  • Single-action revolvers from the frontier period, including Colt Single Action Army variants
  • Early semi-automatic pistols from the late 19th and early 20th centuries, including Luger and Mauser C96 models
  • Lever-action rifles from manufacturers such as Winchester and Marlin produced before 1900
  • Rare or limited-production shotguns with documented provenance, including fine English and American side-by-sides
  • Presentation and engraved firearms with factory or custom embellishment that significantly affects value
  • Military bring-back firearms with documented capture papers or import markings
  • Matched sets and cased pairs of antique pistols or dueling pistols with original accessories
  • Antique firearms with notable provenance, including documented ownership by historical figures or units

How AppraiseItNow Handles Antique Gun Appraisals for Insurance

Our process and deliverables are straightforward, and clients should understand what to expect before engaging us:

  • Appraisers credentialed through organizations including ISA, ASA, and AAA examine each firearm's make, model, caliber, serial number, condition grade, originality, and provenance documentation, applying recent comparable sales data to arrive at a supportable fair market value conclusion
  • Each completed report includes a detailed written description of the firearm, condition notes referenced to recognized grading standards, photographic documentation from multiple angles, the methodology used to determine value, and the appraiser's credentials and certification, all formatted to meet insurer requirements for scheduled endorsements
  • Reports are delivered digitally and are suitable for submission to carriers when adding a scheduled rider, updating existing coverage after a new acquisition, or satisfying insurer requests for documentation on high-value pieces
  • All appraisals are USPAP-compliant, which means the methodology, scope of work, and conclusions meet the professional standards that insurers and courts recognize as credible and defensible

What insurance coverage clients say we are known for

Insurance Coverage Appraisal Reviews: “for me it was well worth it” and “I had a great experience with AppraiseItNow”

  1. Being the appraiser they come back to“I highly recommend them” Nancy S.Mentioned in 9 reviews
  2. Answering fast, and staying reachable while the work runs“Communication was responsive and helpful throughout” David S.Mentioned in 4 reviews
  3. Showing the research and the comparables behind the number“Responsive and thorough” Michael P.Mentioned in 4 reviews
  4. Delivering the finished report ahead of the deadlineMentioned in 2 reviews

Across 10 published insurance coverage appraisal reviews, every one from a client who paid AppraiseItNow for an appraisal, the three things they raise most often are that they would hire us again, how quickly we answer, and how much research is visible in the report.

  • I had a great experience with AppraiseItNow. I needed a formal insurance appraisal for a very unusual and difficult-to-value Pokémon collectible, and their team handled the process professionally from start to finish. Communication was responsive and helpful throughout, and I really appreciated that they took the time to understand the rarity, provenance, and unusual nature of the item rather than treating it like a routine appraisal. The final report was thorough, well organized, and clearly explained the methodology and reasoning behind the valuation. I was very happy with both the finished appraisal and the overall experience working with their team. I’d absolutely use AppraiseItNow again for another specialty collectible appraisal and would recommend them to anyone looking for a professional insurance appraisal.
    David S., Round Hill, VA ·

    Memorabilia & Collectibles Appraisal for Insurance Coverage

  • I never thought about needing something appraised and not being able to find anyone. But we were moving and owned a few pieces of furniture that were of high value. When I realized there was no one in the islands who offered this service, I was grateful to the moving company for finding AppraiseItNow for me. They were quick and communicative, and we had the paperwork we needed within a week. I highly recommend them!
    Nancy S., Kailua, HI ·

    Furniture Appraisal for Insurance Coverage

  • AppraiseItNow's service was expeditious and professional. The report was thorough with plenty of examples and rationale for the valuations. Good service comes at a cost, but for me it was well worth it. Highly recommended!
    Jason O., New York, NY ·

    Personal Property Appraisal for Insurance Coverage

  • Great to work with. Responsive and thorough. Would highly recommend.
    Michael P., Sound Beach, NY ·

    Sports Memorabilia Appraisal for Insurance Coverage

  • Joe made the process to have my piece of furniture appraised extremely easy, efficient and quick. My experience was great and I'd recommend AppraiseItNow to anyone looking for an appraisal.
    Michael H., Corpus Christi, TX ·

    Furniture Appraisal for Insurance Coverage

  • I used AppraiseItNow for the first time last month and I was extremely pleased with the results. I needed an appraisal done for insurance purposes and the level of detail about each of my antique furniture pieces was thorough and very helpful in my being able to get the highest amount possible from my insurance company for the antique items that were damaged. I could see that they spent time making sure that the information she included was correct and current for my antique furniture items in the current market. The team responded to my emails timely to answer any questions I had. I would highly recommend Appraise It Now to get a thorough and professional appraisal done on antique items. I do intend to use them again for other antique furniture and jewelry that I have. Job well done! 😃🤗
    Paige E. , Baldwin, NY ·

    Antique Furniture Appraisal for Insurance Claim

Frequently Asked Questions on Gun Appraisals for Insurance Coverage

Why isn't a standard homeowners policy enough for an antique gun collection?

Because unscheduled firearms are typically subject to a sublimit, commonly in the $1,500 to $3,000 range for theft, no matter what the collection is worth. Scheduling each gun at a documented value converts it to item-specific coverage at the declared amount, which is why carriers ask for an appraisal or purchase records before agreeing to schedule.

What value basis do insurers use when scheduling antique firearms?

Fair market value or agreed value supported by recent comparable sales and NRA condition grading, not original purchase price. Some specialty insurers cap insurable value for out-of-production guns at the 95 percent condition value in the Blue Book of Gun Values, while current-production guns are often scheduled at MSRP. Older, discontinued, or inherited firearms typically require an independent appraisal.

Will a scheduled antique gun still be depreciated at claim time?

Generally no. Scheduled or agreed-value firearm coverage typically pays the declared amount without a separate depreciation deduction, while unscheduled guns under an actual cash value policy are paid at depreciated value. Many owners discover this difference only after a loss, so our insurance appraisals state the standard of value explicitly.

What documentation do carriers want before insuring a firearm collection?

An inventory listing each gun's make, model, caliber or gauge, and serial number, plus photographs and either bills of sale or an appraisal. Carriers commonly require a bill of sale for recent purchases and a current appraisal for older or no-longer-manufactured guns, and custom work or engraving should be documented separately so it can be insured at its own value.