What happens when a South Dakota court orders an appraisement of equipment?
Under SDCL Chapter 21-19, the court appoints three appraisers who must value each item at its actual fair market value where it sits, then file a sworn appraisement signed by at least two of them. That filed document becomes a formal, court-recognized valuation, which is why disputed machinery in South Dakota litigation often runs through a court-structured appraisal.
Can a personal representative hire an appraiser for estate machinery in South Dakota?
Yes. SDCL Section 29A-3-707 lets the personal representative employ a qualified, disinterested appraiser for assets whose value is not readily ascertainable, and different appraisers may be used for different kinds of property. The appraiser's name and address must appear on the inventory next to the items valued, creating a court-facing record of who stood behind each figure.
How are machinery values supported when comparable sales are scarce?
Through the cost approach: current replacement cost from manufacturer quotes and cost guides such as Marshall Valuation Service, less physical, functional, and economic depreciation. When comparables do exist, we pull them from auction platforms such as MachineryTrader, IronPlanet, and BidSpotter and from dealer listings, and the report states which approach carried the conclusion and why.
When does installed machinery stop being personal property in South Dakota?
Only when it effectively merges with the building. In National Food Corp. v. Aurora County, the South Dakota Supreme Court held machinery is normally personal property and becomes a fixture only if removal would materially injure the realty or the machine, or the structure was specially designed to house it. That line decides which tax and appraisal rules apply to a plant’s equipment.
Do liens follow South Dakota equipment after the owner hands it over?
They can. Under SDCL ch. 44-11, a possessory lienholder who surrenders equipment can preserve the lien by filing notice with the register of deeds within 120 days, keeping it valid against most later parties. Recently surrendered machinery can therefore carry encumbrances a buyer cannot see, and our reports note known liens because they directly reduce realizable value.