Vermont Art Appraisers

5.0 on Google110+ 5-star reviews

Artwork appraisals in Vermont for donations, estate tax, insurance, and divorce, prepared in accordance with USPAP and IRS requirements. AppraiseItNow appraises paintings, sculptures, prints, photography, and mixed media across Vermont, including Burlington, Montpelier, and Rutland.

Get an instant response

DEFENSIBLE, USPAP-COMPLIANT ARTWORK APPRAISAL REPORTS — QUALIFIED FOR THE IRS, VERMONT COURTS, LENDERS, INSURERS, AND MORE.

  • IRS
  • Vermont Courts
  • Chase
  • State Farm
  • Goodwill Industries
  • NBT Bank
  • Habitat for Humanity

Credentialed Appraisers Serving Vermont

Between them, AppraiseItNow's fine art appraisers hold ISA designations. These are a few of them, and our reports are written to USPAP for the IRS, Vermont courts, lenders, insurers, and more.

Joe Kattan

Joe Kattan

Owner & CEO

Joe joined AppraiseItNow as a co-owner in 2022 and acquired the company in November 2024 to make a certified, USPAP-compliant appraisal as simple to order as anything else online. A former Bain & Company strategy consultant, Joe leads the entire team and specializes in strategy, growth, and the firm's tech capabilities.

Anne Hay

Anne Hay

Personal Property Appraiser

ISA Accredited Member with 30 years in the trade, from running estate sales and an auction gallery to appraising luxury apparel, furniture, artwork, antiques, and business assets, primarily for IRS tax filings.

Ashley Innes

Ashley Innes

Personal Property Appraiser

ISA Accredited Member specializing in Asian art, with a Master's from SOAS and a Postgraduate Diploma in Asian Art. Ashley chairs the ISA's Antiques, Furnishings, and Decorative Arts committee and appraises for charitable donation, insurance, and equitable distribution.

Aron Blue

Aron Blue

Client Success Manager

Manages each engagement from the first enquiry to the delivered report, and keeps you posted at every step along the way.

  • USPAPWritten to the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice
  • International Society of AppraisersAccredited Member
  • The Appraisal FoundationAuthorized by Congress as the source of appraisal standards
What we look at
The work and its papersThe piece itself in high resolution images, signatures, labels and inscriptions, exhibition and sale history, condition, and whatever prior report or receipt the owner still holds.
Standards we report
Fair market or replacementFair market value for a gift, an estate or a division, retail replacement value for an insurance schedule. The report names which one it used and the date it speaks to.
How it works
Photographs firstMost work is valued from images and documentation, with an appraiser in the room when condition, scale or the size of a collection calls for it.

Woodstock Collectors and Bennington Estates Send Vermont Paintings, Prints, and Bronzes to Our Appraisers

AppraiseItNow appraises paintings, works on paper, sculpture, photography, folk art and studio craft in Vermont for charitable gifts, estate and gift tax filings, insurance schedules and divorce.

Paintings and works on paper

Nineteenth century landscapes through studio work

What a painting brings turns on whose hand made it, the state it is in, and where it has been shown or sold before. We work from recorded results for comparable pieces by the same maker, and the report lists which of those sales carried the conclusion. Where nothing comparable can be found at all, it says so plainly instead of borrowing a price from an unrelated market.

Folk and decorative art

Weathervanes, samplers, and painted furniture

New England folk material is read on surface, form and history far more than on size. A repainted or refinished piece falls steeply against an untouched one, so the report sets out what the condition opinion rests on and what it could not establish.

Sculpture and craft

Bronzes, carvings, and studio glass

Edition size, foundry marks and later casts all move what a sculpture is worth. Where a work belongs to a numbered run we say where in that run it sits, and what other examples from the same run have actually brought at sale.

Two Vermont Owners in Shelburne and Manchester Can Need Opposite Numbers for One Painting

An insurance schedule asks what putting the same work back would cost at retail. A charitable gift or an estate asks what it would bring on the open market. Those are different questions, and the distance between the answers is often wide.

Charitable gifts

Gifts to a museum or a historical society

A donated work is read at fair market value on the date the donor parted with it, resting on recorded sales of comparable pieces. We also set down what the institution actually received, and the condition it was in when it arrived.

Estates and divisions

Collections split between heirs

Dividing a collection needs a figure for each piece that both sides can live with, all read on one date. We value piece by piece where works are individually significant, and by category where a group only makes sense held together. Where pieces are likely to be sold rather than kept, the report notes what selling them would take out of the proceeds.

Vermont Gives a Donor a Small Credit and Leaves a Collector's Gain Outside Its Exclusion

Two Vermont income tax rules decide what giving away or selling a work of art is actually worth to its owner.

Donation credit

$20,000

The contribution ceiling the Vermont credit is figured on

Vermont Turns a Charitable Gift Into a Credit Figured on the First Part of It

Under 32 V.S.A. § 5822(d)(3), a Vermont individual receives a nonrefundable credit of five percent of the first $20,000 in charitable contributions made during the taxable year, for contributions allowable under 26 U.S.C. § 170, and the statute makes it available even to a taxpayer who takes the federal standard deduction. The state side of a gift therefore tops out at $1,000 however valuable the work is, while the federal deduction continues to turn on the appraised value. Estates and trusts do not get the credit.

32 V.S.A. § 5822(d)(3)

Gain at a sale

40 percent

The Vermont reduction, and the definition that narrows it

What Vermont Takes Off a Capital Gain Depends on a Federal Definition It Borrows

32 V.S.A. § 5811(21)(B)(ii) lets a taxpayer reduce Vermont taxable income by either the first $5,000 of adjusted net capital gain income or forty percent of that income from assets held more than three years, with real estate used as a residence, depreciable personal property other than farm property and standing timber, and publicly traded stocks, bonds and other financial instruments all excluded, and the whole reduction capped at forty percent of federal taxable income or $350,000, whichever is less. The measure is adjusted net capital gain as 26 U.S.C. § 1(h) defines it, and that definition subtracts 28 percent rate gain, which under § 1(h)(4) and (5) is where gain on a collectible is gathered. Section 408(m) counts any work of art as a collectible.

32 V.S.A. § 5811(21)(B)(ii)

What clients say we are known for

AppraiseItNow Reviews: “AppraiseItNow was amazing” and “The appraisal was done very well”

  1. Being the appraiser they come back toMentioned in 55 reviews
  2. Answering fast, and staying reachable while the work runs“Joe was always prompt and responsive” Dan R.Mentioned in 47 reviews
  3. Showing the research and the comparables behind the numberMentioned in 35 reviews
  4. Delivering the finished report ahead of the deadlineMentioned in 31 reviews
  5. Taking on items other appraisers had already turned down“AppraiseItNow did an excellent job appraising our unique art collection” Dan R.Mentioned in 15 reviews

Across 110+ published AppraiseItNow reviews the picture is consistent: every one is from a client who paid us for an appraisal, and the three things they raise most often are that they would hire us again, how quickly we answer, and how much research is visible in the report.

  • I called a few appraisers and none of them returned my calls. AppraiseItNow was great. Super responsive. They provided the detailed appraisal within just a few days from my request.
    Ryan C. ·

    Artwork Appraisal for Charitable Donation

  • The appraisal was done very well. Since he was a local artist here in Charleston, SC, they took the time to study and review Jim Booth’s art. His work has made him extremely famous, which can make an appraisal challenging, but they did a superb job and clearly explained how they arrived at the appraisal value. I highly recommend Appraise It Now and will use them again for all my artwork.
    Lonnie L. ·

    Artwork Appraisal for Insurance Coverage

  • AppraiseItNow did an excellent job appraising our unique art collection. Joe was always prompt and responsive, and he and his team delivered a thorough, well-supported appraisal in just a couple of weeks, even during the holiday season. I was genuinely impressed. Thank you for the great work!
    Dan R. ·

    Artwork Appraisal for Insurance Coverage

  • AppraiseItNow was amazing! My father passed with a large volume of artwork & I had no idea what it was worth. Their team was incredibly helpful and quick to respond with text and/or email to any questions as well as a status update along the way. Highly recommend!
    Christina W. ·

    Artwork Appraisal for Probate

  • I recently requested a retroactive appraisal for fine art from AppraiseItNow. I received excellent service from intake to delivery. The appraisal was delivered on time and the content of the appraisal absolutely met my expectations!
    James H. ·

    Artwork Appraisal

  • From the start they were very responsive, price competitive, and had a quick turn around time. Thank you so much to Joe who was very sweet in responding to my emails; I am looking forward to utilizing AppraiseItNow for many years to come.
    Chris S. ·

AppraiseItNow appraises fine art for estate tax, gift tax, charitable donations, divorce, and insurance claims

Given the USPAP-compliant nature of AppraiseItNow’s appraisal reports, we prepare our deliverables for major legal, tax, and financial reporting purposes for individual and commercial clients.

Popular uses of our appraisal reports include:‍

Taxes, Estates & Financial Planning

Life Events & Special Circumstances

  • Divorce
  • Social Security reporting or Medicaid Application Filings
  • E-2 visa applications

Insurance & Risk Management

Frequently Asked Questions on Vermont Art Appraisers

Why is my insurance appraisal higher than fair market value for the same artwork?

Because insurance appraisals for artwork typically use retail replacement value, the cost to replace the piece at retail, while estate, gift, and donation work uses fair market value. The two standards can produce very different numbers for the same painting, so we confirm the intended use before the assignment begins and state the value definition in the report.

Does a larger painting automatically appraise higher?

No, size and material alone do not determine price. Empirical market studies show artist identity, condition, and provenance each often have larger quantified effects on value than dimensions or medium. A small work on paper by a sought-after artist can outvalue a wall-sized canvas by an unlisted painter many times over.

Will Vermont's estate tax reach the artwork in my estate?

It can. Under 32 V.S.A. § 7442a, a Vermont taxable estate under $5,000,000 owes nothing, and one of $5,000,000 or more is taxed at 16 percent of the excess over that figure, with the result multiplied by the Vermont share of the gross estate. Tangible personal property located in Vermont, artwork included, belongs to that share, and all values are the ones finally determined for federal estate tax purposes. Date-of-death appraisals establish the values behind that calculation.

What does the IRS require when Vermont artwork is donated to charity?

A qualified appraisal and Form 8283 once the claimed deduction for the artwork exceeds $5,000. Donations of art appraised at $50,000 or more are routinely reviewed by the IRS Art Advisory Panel, so the comparable sales and market analysis behind the number need to withstand specialist scrutiny. We prepare donation appraisals to the IRS fair market value standard with documented comparables.