Wisconsin Gun Appraisers

5.0 on Google110+ 5-star reviews

Gun appraisals in Wisconsin for donations, estate tax, divorce, and probate, prepared in accordance with USPAP and IRS requirements. AppraiseItNow appraises handguns, rifles, shotguns, antique firearms, and collectible guns across Wisconsin, including Milwaukee, Madison, and Green Bay.

Get an instant response

DEFENSIBLE, USPAP-COMPLIANT FIREARMS APPRAISAL REPORTS — QUALIFIED FOR THE IRS, WISCONSIN COURTS, LENDERS, INSURERS, AND MORE.

  • IRS
  • Goodwill Industries
  • Chase
  • State Farm
  • Habitat for Humanity
  • The Salvation Army
  • Associated Bank
  • Wisconsin Courts

Credentialed Appraisers Serving Wisconsin

Between them, AppraiseItNow's personal property appraisers hold ISA and CAGA designations. These are a few of them, and our reports are written to USPAP for the IRS, Wisconsin courts, lenders, insurers, and more.

Joe Kattan

Joe Kattan

Owner & CEO

Joe joined AppraiseItNow as a co-owner in 2022 and acquired the company in November 2024 to make a certified, USPAP-compliant appraisal as simple to order as anything else online. A former Bain & Company strategy consultant, Joe leads the entire team and specializes in strategy, growth, and the firm's tech capabilities.

Anne Hay

Anne Hay

Personal Property Appraiser

ISA Accredited Member with 30 years in the trade, from running estate sales and an auction gallery to appraising luxury apparel, furniture, artwork, antiques, and business assets, primarily for IRS tax filings.

Jason Dolph

Jason Dolph

Machinery & Equipment Appraiser

Third-generation auctioneer and CAGA Certified Appraiser with more than 20 years valuing machinery, equipment, vehicles, business assets, and estates for banks, attorneys, and trustees across the Carolinas.

Ashley Innes

Ashley Innes

Personal Property Appraiser

ISA Accredited Member specializing in Asian art, with a Master's from SOAS and a Postgraduate Diploma in Asian Art. Ashley chairs the ISA's Antiques, Furnishings, and Decorative Arts committee and appraises for charitable donation, insurance, and equitable distribution.

Aron Blue

Aron Blue

Client Success Manager

Manages each engagement from the first enquiry to the delivered report, and keeps you posted at every step along the way.

  • USPAPWritten to the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice
  • International Society of AppraisersAccredited Member
  • Certified Appraisers Guild of AmericaCertified Appraiser
  • The Appraisal FoundationAuthorized by Congress as the source of appraisal standards
Collections we see
Across WisconsinMilwaukee and the southeast, the Fox Valley, the Driftless, and the lake country north of Wausau.
How it is delivered
OnlineA list and close photographs from the owner, with a visit where the collection or the doubt is big enough.
What the file needs first
A list and photographsWhat is in the safe, what came with each piece, and anything on paper that puts a date on it.

Deer Rifles, Shotguns, Handguns, and Collections in Rhinelander and La Crosse Are Wisconsin Firearms We Value

AppraiseItNow appraises deer rifles, shotguns, handguns, military and collectible arms, and whole collections in Wisconsin for insurance scheduling, loss and theft claims, charitable donations, estate work, and lending.

Insurance scheduling

Each gun on its own line, described well enough to replace

A rider that reads as a count of firearms and a total is worth very little after a fire or a theft. We put the maker, model, caliber, finish, and the condition as found under every line, with the figure the policy asks for.

Loss and theft claims

Rebuilding a value for guns that are gone

When the collection has already left the house, value has to be built from what the owner can still show: old photographs, receipts, prior schedules, and the record of what was kept where. We write what that evidence supports and say where it runs out.

Donations and lending

Pieces going to a nonprofit or standing behind a loan

A charity needs the figure a piece would draw from the buyers who actually want it, measured on the day the gift was made. A lender needs what an orderly sale would return instead. We write whichever one the file calls for and name it.

We Value Wisconsin Firearms From the Owner's Photographs, and in Person in Stevens Point or Hayward When a Collection Needs It

Most Wisconsin firearm files never need a visit. We work from the owner's list, close photographs of the markings and the wear, and whatever paperwork came with each piece, and we travel when a collection is large enough or a gun uncertain enough to earn the trip.

What moves the number

Originality, not just condition

A refinished receiver, a replacement stock, or a shortened barrel takes a piece out of one market and drops it into another. We set down what is original and what is not, then price the gun in the market it actually belongs to.

Ammunition and accessories

What sits beside the guns in the safe

Optics, magazines, reloading equipment, and a wall of ammunition are separate assets with their own markets, and they get left off a schedule more often than anything else. We list them, because after a loss they are part of what has to be replaced.

Keeping a schedule current

An old appraisal under a new policy

A schedule written years ago sits under the market on some pieces and over it on others, because models go out of production and runs of ammunition come and go. We bring an existing schedule current rather than start it over.

Wisconsin Runs Its Own Handgun Check, Which Shapes How a Milwaukee or Green Bay Collection Actually Sells

One Wisconsin rule stands between a handgun and its buyer, and the state runs it rather than the federal system.

Transfers

Five days

the limit on the state's own handgun check

A Wisconsin Handgun Moves Through a State Check and a Long Gun Through the Federal One

Wisconsin runs its own point of contact for handguns. A registered Wisconsin firearms dealer starts the eligibility check with the state justice department's firearms section, which searches twelve state and national criminal justice databases to decide whether the buyer may own a firearm and buy a handgun. The check is to be complete within five days, counted without weekends or holidays, and the dealer may not transfer the firearm until the state has approved the sale. Long gun checks go instead to the federal instant background check system. For a collection being sold or consigned, the handguns and the long guns therefore move on two different clocks, which is part of what an orderly sale of a Wisconsin collection actually looks like.

Wisconsin Department of Justice

What Wisconsin clients say we are known for

Wisconsin Appraisal Reviews: “the company exceeded all of my expectations” and “They are knowledgeable and complete their appraisal quickly”

  1. Being the appraiser they come back to“I highly recommend their services” Bruce A.Mentioned in 17 reviews
  2. Answering fast, and staying reachable while the work runs“Communication was responsive and helpful throughout” David S.Mentioned in 10 reviews
  3. Showing the research and the comparables behind the number“The final report was thorough, well organized” David S.Mentioned in 8 reviews
  4. Delivering the finished report ahead of the deadline“They are knowledgeable and complete their appraisal quickly” Janet K.Mentioned in 7 reviews
  5. Taking on items other appraisers had already turned downMentioned in 5 reviews

Across 28 published Wisconsin appraisal reviews, every one from a client who paid AppraiseItNow for an appraisal, the three things they raise most often are that they would hire us again, how quickly we answer, and how much research is visible in the report.

  • It is a pleasure to work with Joe and his team. They communicate every step along the way and made the process simple for us to have more than 35 firearms appraised. It was all done in a timely manner and the final report is easy to understand. I highly recommend their services.
    Bruce A. ·

    Gun Appraisal for Probate

  • I was skeptical at first, but the company exceeded all of my expectations. The team responded quickly to every question, and the service was excellent. They’re now my go to source for my collection. I’ve used them twice already, and I plan to use them several more times.
    Robert Y. ·

    Firearms Appraisal for Personal Use

  • The folks at AppraiseItNow Inc. were so easy to work with. From the initial contact to the receipt of the 8283 form it was a breeze. Their communications with me were wonderfully concise. And their requests for additional information were clear and easy to fulfill. I recommend them highly for your needs.
    Bill H. ·

    Piano Appraisal for Charitable Donation

  • I had a great experience with AppraiseItNow. I needed a formal insurance appraisal for a very unusual and difficult-to-value Pokémon collectible, and their team handled the process professionally from start to finish. Communication was responsive and helpful throughout, and I really appreciated that they took the time to understand the rarity, provenance, and unusual nature of the item rather than treating it like a routine appraisal. The final report was thorough, well organized, and clearly explained the methodology and reasoning behind the valuation. I was very happy with both the finished appraisal and the overall experience working with their team. I’d absolutely use AppraiseItNow again for another specialty collectible appraisal and would recommend them to anyone looking for a professional insurance appraisal.
    David S. ·

    Memorabilia & Collectibles Appraisal for Insurance Coverage

  • I used AppraiseItNow for the first time last month and I was extremely pleased with the results. I needed an appraisal done for insurance purposes and the level of detail about each of my antique furniture pieces was thorough and very helpful in my being able to get the highest amount possible from my insurance company for the antique items that were damaged. I could see that they spent time making sure that the information she included was correct and current for my antique furniture items in the current market. The team responded to my emails timely to answer any questions I had. I would highly recommend Appraise It Now to get a thorough and professional appraisal done on antique items. I do intend to use them again for other antique furniture and jewelry that I have. Job well done! 😃🤗
    Paige E. ·

    Antique Furniture Appraisal for Insurance Claim

  • This team is so easy to work with. They are very professional and pleasant, and respond quickly to any questions. They are knowledgeable and complete their appraisal quickly. I feel their fee is reasonable for the work they do. They are properly licensed, so I feel they can be trusted, especially after speaking with them. It is clear they know what they are talking about. Their process is easy to follow and complete. I highly recommend the AppraiseItNow team and look forward to working with them again.
    Janet K. ·

    Personal Property Appraisal for Estate Distribution

AppraiseItNow appraises every category of personal property for gift tax, estate tax, charitable donations, divorce, and insurance claims

Given the USPAP-compliant nature of AppraiseItNow’s appraisal reports, we prepare our deliverables for major legal, tax, and financial reporting purposes for individual and commercial clients.

Popular uses of our appraisal reports include:‍

Taxes, Estates & Financial Planning

Life Events & Special Circumstances

  • Divorce
  • Social Security reporting or Medicaid Application Filings
  • E-2 visa applications

Insurance & Risk Management

Frequently Asked Questions on Wisconsin Gun Appraisers

How is firearm condition graded in an appraisal?

Against standardized scales: NRA Condition Standards for modern guns and percentage-of-original-finish measures for collectibles, supported by serial verification, matching-component checks, bore inspection, and function testing. Grading discipline matters because a single condition step can move value materially, especially near collector-grade thresholds.

How do Wisconsin probate courts handle firearm values?

Through the statewide Inventory (Form PR-1811), which lists each asset at fair market value as of the date of death; those values also drive the probate inventory filing fee. Wisconsin uses no probate referee system, so the personal representative may engage any qualified appraiser, and Wisconsin imposes no estate or inheritance tax.

Are guns split 50/50 in a Wisconsin divorce?

Presumptively, yes. Wis. Stat. § 767.61 presumes equal division of marital property, including firearms, though courts may deviate after weighing statutory factors, and assets are generally valued as of the divorce or final hearing. A documented fair market value appraisal of the collection keeps that division grounded in market evidence.

Can a gun shop's offer substitute for an estate appraisal in Wisconsin?

It shouldn't. Wis. Stat. § 865.20 lets the personal representative employ a qualified and disinterested appraiser for assets whose value is subject to reasonable doubt, and Wisconsin practice guidance warns against relying on shops or prospective buyers, whose numbers can be biased and can overlook collector or historical value. A disinterested appraisal also protects the representative when values must be equalized among beneficiaries.

What extra steps do NFA firearms in a Wisconsin estate require?

Locate the ATF Form 4 before anything is moved. Wisconsin estate guidance stresses that federally registered items such as machine guns, short-barreled rifles and shotguns, and suppressors should stay put until the executor finds the registration paperwork, and ownership cannot pass until a new Form 4, the $200 tax stamp, and federal registration to the transferee are complete. Those constraints also shape the realistic market for such pieces.